RoR persistency vs. JPA (Java SE/EE5) - or what is easier?

I got an interesting comment from sam (thank you)  probably from RoR space. It explains how the inconsistencies are solved using versioning INSIDE a transaction:

Ruby On Rails code::

   Employee.transaction do
     emp = = 'Kurz'
     emp.surname = 'Martin'!
     emp2 = Employee.find(
     emp3 = Employee.find(
     emp2.surname = 'Marta' = 'Hürlimann'
     puts "before!"!
     puts "before!"!
     pp emp
     raise "Rollback"
    puts $!

==> Attempted to update a stale object


I could not resist and wrote the same functionality with CMP 2.1:

---EJB 2.1 ----

EmployeRemote employee = serviceLocator.getHome().findByPrimaryKey(vo.getId());
//no saving needed
EmployeRemote employee2 = employeHome.findByPrimaryKey(vo.getId());
EmployeRemote employee3 = employeHome.findByPrimaryKey(vo.getId());

Inconsistencies not possible: Reason: employee == employee2 == employee3 (you get always the same instance back)

I also provided a Java Persistence API (JPA) implementation. Public fields are used, but setters were also possible:

---Entity 3.0 (Java EE 5) ---

EntityManager em; // will be injected by container

Employe employee = em.find(Employee.class,employee.getId());  = "Kurz";  // setters are also possible
employee.surname = "Martin";

//no saving needed
Employe employee2 = em.find(Employee.class,employee.getId());
Employe´employee3 = em.find(Employee.class,employee.getId());
employee2.surname = "Marta"; = "Hürlimann";

...also here: inconsistencies not possible: Reason: employee == employee2 == employee3 (you get always the same instance back)...

And now the interesting question: which implementation is more compact, expressive and easier to understand? :-) The Java EE container cares about transactions, and consistency, so no save and transaction control operations are needed. Also the exception: ==> Attempted to update a stale object cannot happen and you have not to care about this stuff. Things become more interesting in case you are changing some objects in a graph and not only attributes :-).

ActiveRecord is great, but you have to know what you are doing and it is not always easier than OR-mapping...

NEW: Online Workhop Effective WebApps without Frameworks is also coming to: MUC Airport.

Airport MUC workshops: Web (SPA, PWAs, Offline, Desktop, Mobile) Applications Essentials and Effective Web Applications. No migrations. #usetheplatform

Podcast: and newsletter:

A book about rethinking Java EE Patterns


Post a Comment:
  • HTML Syntax: NOT allowed
Online Workshops
...the last 150 posts
...the last 10 comments